Echo vs HomePod vs Nest vs Sonos 2026: What Alexa+ Costs, What Each Speaker Records, and Which to Buy

Echo vs HomePod vs Google vs Sonos in 2026: what Alexa+ costs over three years, what each smart speaker records and which to buy (Verdict Picks)

If you want a speaker that cannot record you, the Sonos Era 100 SL is the only one here: Sonos says it has no microphones at all, and it carries no subscription. For everything else the real question is the monthly fee, not the price on the box. Alexa+ is free with Prime and $19.99 a month without it, which is $719.64 over three years; Google's Gemini Live needs a plan that starts at $10 a month; Apple and Sonos charge nothing today. This guide compares six speakers on what each maker says it keeps, what the assistant costs, and whether to buy before or after Black Friday (November 27). We compared makers' pages and published tests; we did not test the speakers ourselves.

Guides: Robot Vacuums · Wireless Earbuds · Smart Glasses · Power Stations · Best Sellers · Price Check · Recall Check · Follow

Published November 6, 2026 · Updated November 6, 2026 · By Prof. H, professor of AI and robotics (Prof H Lab) (Vera, our host, is an illustrated persona) · The Amazon buttons on this page are paid links: as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How we make money · How we rank

Key takeaways

  • Records nothing: the Sonos Era 100 SL, $189 at Sonos. Sonos says it has no internal microphones, so it has no voice control and nothing to delete. It was about 21% off on October 6, 2026 (Gizmodo); wait for a repeat.
  • Alexa+ costs $0 extra only if you already have Prime. Amazon lists it at $19.99 a month otherwise ($719.64 over 36 months), with a limited free chat tier on Alexa.com and the app (Amazon, September 1, 2026).
  • The only live speaker sale is Google's. The Google Home Speaker is $79.99 through December 2, 2026 (Google Store, November 6), but Gemini Live needs Google Home Premium at $10 or $20 a month.
  • The catch for every voice speaker: each keeps something by default. Echo keeps audio until you set 3 or 18 months or choose not to save; Google keeps activity 18 months if Home History is on; Apple keeps no audio unless you opt in.
  • Skip to the buy box ↓ (the exact models to order and what to check on the listing)
한국어 요약 (Korean summary)

[제휴 링크 포함] 이 글의 아마존 링크를 통해 구매하시면 Verdict Picks가 수수료를 받을 수 있습니다. · 스마트 스피커를 고를 때 가격표보다 중요한 것은 월 구독료와 음성 데이터 보관 방식입니다. Sonos가 마이크가 전혀 없다고 밝힌 Era 100 SL(공식 189달러)은 녹음할 것이 아예 없어 첫 번째 추천입니다. Alexa+는 아마존 프라임 회원에게는 추가 비용이 없고, 비회원은 월 19.99달러(3년 719.64달러)입니다. 구글 홈 스피커는 11월 6일 기준 79.99달러(12월 2일까지)로 유일하게 진행 중인 할인이 있지만 Gemini Live는 월 10~20달러의 Premium이 필요합니다. 애플 HomePod mini 2는 149달러이며 구독료는 없으나 Siri AI는 아직 출시되지 않았습니다. 에코 계열은 블랙프라이데이(11월 27일)까지 기다리는 편이 낫습니다. 저희는 제품을 직접 테스트하지 않고 제조사 문서와 공개된 평가를 비교했습니다.

Vera's 10-second verdict

No mic, no fee: the Sonos Era 100 SL.Prime member? An Echo costs nothing extra.Google Home Speaker is on sale to December 2.Vera, your Verdict Picks host · illustration
Sonos Era 100 SL No microphones · no voice assistant · Wi-Fi and Bluetooth · $189 list Sonos Era 100 SL
Our first pick · it cannot record you

Sonos Era 100 SL

$189 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026). About 21% off ($149) on Oct 6, 2026 per Gizmodo; Best Buy lists it at $189 in a search result.

  • Buy it if you want good sound and a speaker with nothing to record: Sonos says it has no internal microphones, so there is no voice data to keep and no subscription.
  • Skip it if you want to say "play my playlist" or ask the weather: it has no voice control at all, and Android phones cannot run full Trueplay room tuning (iPhone only, Sonos and TechRadar).
  • What owners and testers say: No owner failure threads found for the SL itself. Sonos Community (March 10, 2026): it will not stereo pair with a Sonos One, One SL or Play:1. Best Buy search snippet, Nov 6, 2026: 4.7 stars on 27 reviews (UNVERIFIED, small pool).
See today's price on Amazon → (paid link)

Which smart speaker should you buy?

Pick by the phone in your pocket and what you are willing to pay each month: Sonos Era 100 SL if you want no recording, HomePod mini 2 for iPhones, Google Home Speaker for Android, Echo for Prime members.

If you…BuyWhyOr consider
want nothing recordedSonos Era 100 SLNo microphones (Sonos), no plan, good sound (TechRadar, June 21, 2026)Era 100 if you want voice with a physical mic switch
live on iPhonesHomePod mini 2$149, no fee, audio not stored unless you opt in (Apple, Oct 26, 2026)Wait for Siri AI to ship (no date from Apple)
use Android and Google HomeGoogle Home Speaker$79.99 to Dec 2 at the Google Store; mute switchSkip if you will not pay for Premium for Gemini Live
already have Prime and an Alexa homeEcho Dot MaxAlexa+ included; Zigbee, Matter, Thread hubEcho Studio for sound; wait for Black Friday
want the best soundSonos Era 100Tom's Guide preferred it to the Echo Studio on soundEcho Studio if you live in Alexa
do not have Prime and hate feesAnything but an EchoAlexa+ is $719.64 over three years on its ownEra 100 SL or HomePod mini 2

What does Alexa+ really cost over three years?

Nothing extra if you already pay for Prime, $719.64 if you do not, and between $0 and $600 for Google depending on the plan.

Amazon's own announcement (updated September 1, 2026) says Alexa+ is "available in the U.S. for $19.99 per month and included at no additional cost to Prime members", with a free tier that lets non-Prime customers try the chat experience on Alexa.com and in the app. We do not state Prime's own fee here because we could not read it on an Amazon page today; check it before you count Prime as free. Google's plan prices are from the Google Store (November 6, 2026). Apple and Sonos list no assistant fee.

SpeakerAssistant planPer month36 monthsSource
Echo (Prime member)Alexa+ included$0 extra$0 extraAmazon, Sept 1, 2026
Echo (no Prime)Alexa+$19.99$719.64Amazon, Sept 1, 2026
Google Home SpeakerFree basics; Premium Standard$10 or $100/yr$0 / $300 annual ($360 monthly)Google Store, Nov 6, 2026
Google Home SpeakerPremium Advanced$20 or $200/yr$600 annual ($720 monthly)Google Store, Nov 6, 2026
HomePod mini 2None found$0$0 (Apple says expanded Siri AI access will cost a fee later, no amount)Apple newsroom, Oct 13, 2026
Sonos Era 100 / SLNone$0$0Sonos, Sept 8, 2026

Two cautions. The Google Home Speaker is advertised with a Premium trial; the press said six months, but Google's own store page says 30 days (November 6, 2026), so assume 30. And the plan price is only the assistant: electricity is small. Sonos publishes idle power of 1.98 watts for the Era 100 and 1.62 watts for the SL, about $3.15 and $2.58 a year at the U.S. residential average of 18.16 cents per kilowatt hour (EIA, August 2026, preliminary); we found no official idle figure for the Echo, Google or Apple speakers. Our broader math on AI subscriptions is in Prof H Lab's real monthly cost of AI (Prof. H runs that site; this one earns commissions, that one does not).

What each speaker keeps, and how to delete it Default retention and the mute control, from each maker's own page Speaker Default retention Delete or limit it Mic off Sonos Era 100 SL Nothing: no microphones Nothing to delete Not needed HomePod mini 2 Audio not stored unless you opt in;requests tied to a random ID for 6 months Home app, Siri History, Delete SiriHistory Voice or Home app (noswitch found) Sonos Era 100 Classic Sonos Voice on the speaker,nothing saved; Alexa recordings go toAmazon Amazon's settings for Alexa Switch on the back Google HomeSpeaker Activity saved 18 months if Home Historyis on; training use off by default myactivity.google.com/product/home;auto-delete 3, 18 or 36 months Physical switch Echo Dot Max /Studio Recordings kept until you set 3 or 18months, or not to save (transcripts kept30 days) Alexa app, More, Alexa Privacy Mic button Sources: Amazon Alexa privacy FAQ (undated, read Nov 6, 2026), Apple Siri privacy page (Oct 26, 2026) and HomePod guide, Google Gemini for Homeactivity page, Sonos privacy statement (Sept 2026). Settings change; check your app.
What each maker says it keeps by default and how to delete it, from each maker's own privacy page read on November 6, 2026.

What does each smart speaker record?

All of them listen for a wake word, and all of them except the Sonos Era 100 SL send some voice data to a cloud when you speak; the difference is what is kept and for how long.

Amazon Echo: kept until you change it

Amazon's privacy FAQ (undated, read November 6, 2026) says you can review and delete recordings under More, then Alexa Privacy in the app, or at amazon.com/alexaprivacysettings. You can auto-delete after 3 or 18 months, or choose not to save recordings. If you choose not to save, voice recordings are deleted after processing, but text transcripts are kept for 30 days after your last interaction in a chat, and Voice ID stops working. The microphone button disconnects power to the microphones. A common worry is stale: in March 2025 Amazon removed "Do Not Send Voice Recordings", but TechRadar (March 18, 2025) reported it affected exactly three models (Echo Dot 4th gen, Echo Show 10 and Echo Show 15), not every Echo. Prof H Lab covers the exit and the ads: how to turn off Alexa+ and Alexa+ ads on the Echo Show.

Apple HomePod mini: audio not stored unless you opt in

Apple's Siri privacy page (dated October 26, 2026) says "Your audio data is not stored by Apple unless you opt in to Improve Siri and Dictation"; if you opt in, Apple may keep it for up to two years. Apple's HomePod guide says request history is tied to a random identifier for 6 months, and you delete it in the Home app under Siri History, Delete Siri History. We found no physical mute switch on the HomePod mini; you turn off listening by voice or in the Home app (UNVERIFIED that none exists on the 2nd generation).

Google Home Speaker: 18 months if Home History is on

Google's Gemini for Home page says that by default activity saves for 18 months when Voice Match and Home History are on; you can choose 3, 18 or 36 months auto-delete and delete at myactivity.google.com/product/home. Using your recordings to improve services, including training generative AI, is a separate setting that is off by default. The speaker has a physical mute toggle on the bottom (Google Store). For the step-by-step on older Nest devices, see Prof H Lab's guide to turning off Gemini on Google Home.

Sonos: nothing saved on the SL, a choice on the Era 100

Sonos's privacy statement (September 2026) says classic Sonos Voice is processed on the device with no audio saved or sent to the cloud; the optional Sonos 27voice upgrade sends your command to Sonos cloud infrastructure for AI processing, and we did not find a retention period for it. If you use Alexa on the Era 100, the recording goes to Amazon and Sonos keeps no copy. The Era 100 has a switch on the back that disconnects power to its microphones, and the Era 100 SL, Sonos says, has no microphone. A 2020 Mozilla *Privacy Not Included entry praised the older mic-less Sonos One SL on the same point (snippet only; older product).

Does any of this change what the experts say?

Not much has been independently tested on the 2025 and 2026 models. Consumer Reports' smart speaker privacy guide (Allen St. John, updated October 2022) predates Alexa+, Gemini for Home and the HomePod mini 2, and Northeastern and Imperial College researchers (2020) found accidental activations of 1.5 to 19 times a day when TV audio played near older speakers, with recordings usually under 10 seconds and no evidence of constant recording (secondary coverage). So what we can compare is the makers' own stated defaults, not measurements.

Which six speakers should you consider?

One card each, ranked by how little each keeps and charges, with who should buy it and who should skip it.

Sonos Era 100 SL No microphones · no voice assistant · Wi-Fi and Bluetooth · $189 list Sonos Era 100 SL
1. Our first pick · it cannot record you

Sonos Era 100 SL

$189 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026). About 21% off ($149) on Oct 6, 2026 per Gizmodo; Best Buy lists it at $189 in a search result.

  • Buy it if you want good sound and a speaker with nothing to record: Sonos says it has no internal microphones, so there is no voice data to keep and no subscription.
  • Skip it if you want to say "play my playlist" or ask the weather: it has no voice control at all, and Android phones cannot run full Trueplay room tuning (iPhone only, Sonos and TechRadar).
  • What owners and testers say: No owner failure threads found for the SL itself. Sonos Community (March 10, 2026): it will not stereo pair with a Sonos One, One SL or Play:1. Best Buy search snippet, Nov 6, 2026: 4.7 stars on 27 reviews (UNVERIFIED, small pool).
HomePod mini 2 S10 chip · Siri · Matter and Thread hub · $149 HomePod mini 2
2. Best for an iPhone home

Apple HomePod mini (2nd generation)

$149 at Apple and $149.99 at Target (Nov 6, 2026); $144.99 at Costco (Oct 23, 2026, SlashGear).

  • Buy it if your household lives on iPhones and you want the shortest documented retention and no monthly fee.
  • Skip it if you need Siri AI today: Apple says it is "coming in a future software update" with no date, and only classic Siri works now (Cult of Mac, Nov 2, 2026). Android homes should skip it.
  • What owners and testers say: On sale since Oct 30, so no months-long owner reports exist yet. Cult of Mac (Nov 2, 2026) gave it 5 of 5. The first-generation mini's forum complaints are about false triggers and glitches after software 26.x (Apple Community, May 20, 2026).
Google HomeSpeaker Gemini for Home · mute switch · $79.99 sale to Dec 2 Google Home Speaker
3. The one live sale · Gemini needs a plan

Google Home Speaker

$79.99 at the Google Store, from $99.99, through Dec 2, 2026 (Google Store, Nov 6; 9to5Google, Nov 2).

  • Buy it if your home runs on Google Home and Android, and you want the speaker at its first discount.
  • Skip it if you want the Gemini conversation features without paying: Gemini Live needs Google Home Premium at $10 or $20 a month (Google Store, Nov 6, 2026). There is no way back to Google Assistant on speakers.
  • What owners and testers say: No months-later owner reports yet (on sale since June 25). BGR (Aug 18, 2026) measured 5 to 10 seconds to turn on a light after a couple of weeks; Engadget (June 24, 2026) rated it 8 of 10 but called the platform buggy.
Echo Dot Max Alexa+ · Zigbee, Matter, Thread hub · $119.99 at Target Echo Dot Max
4. Best for Alexa homes · wait for a deal

Amazon Echo Dot Max (2025)

$119.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026). Past cuts of 10% (Black Friday 2025), 25% (May 2026) and 35% (June 2026) per 9to5Toys and Gizmodo.

  • Buy it if you already pay for Prime (Alexa+ is included) and want an Alexa hub that also covers Zigbee, Matter and Thread.
  • Skip it if you do not have Prime: Alexa+ is $19.99 a month on its own (Amazon, Sept 1, 2026), $719.64 over three years. Also skip it if you care most about sound: PCWorld found it small and muddy.
  • What owners and testers say: PCWorld (Jan 21, 2026, about two months of use) called Alexa+ "still a work in progress". Reddit threads we read (mirror snapshots, Jan to Apr 2026) recur on slow replies and erratic routines; a German site reported late alarms in Sept 2026, which we could not confirm.
Echo Studio Dolby Atmos · Alexa+ · home hub · $219.99 at Target Echo Studio
5. Best sound from Alexa

Amazon Echo Studio (2025)

$219.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026). Black Friday 2025 low was about 14% off (9to5Toys, Dec 12, 2025).

  • Buy it if you want the best Alexa sound and a home theatre add-on and will wait for a sale.
  • Skip it if sound is the main point: Tom's Guide said those focused on audio will still prefer the Sonos Era 100. Skip it too if you are not on Prime, for the same Alexa+ reason.
  • Reddit (mirror, April 2026): one 2025 Echo Studio owner says replies were slow since day one; that is a single comment. Engadget and TechRadar found the sound inconsistent against the original (summaries only).
Sonos Era 100 Alexa · Sonos Voice · mic switch · $219 list Sonos Era 100
6. Best sound with a mic switch

Sonos Era 100

$219 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026). Past cuts: 20% (Black Friday 2023, Engadget), 18% (June 25, 2026, 9to5Toys).

  • Buy it if you want the best-sounding speaker here and voice control you can cut with a physical switch on the back.
  • Skip it if you do not want a microphone in the room: pick the SL. Whether Alexa+ works on the Era 100 is unconfirmed, and Sonos 27voice (cloud-processed) is early access later this fall.
  • What owners and testers say: Retailer pages recur on the Sonos app, drops and no Google Assistant. Best Buy search snippet, Nov 6, 2026: about 4.7 stars on 1,300+ reviews (UNVERIFIED).

How do they sound and what do they control?

Sound comes from published reviews, so treat it as opinion. Tom's Guide (Mike Prospero, October 29, 2025) called the Echo Studio the best smart speaker for an Amazon-centric home theatre but said those focused on audio will prefer the Sonos Era 100. TechRadar (Josephine Watson, November 26, 2025) found the Echo Dot Max's audio decent and its price "a bit pricier than I'd expect"; PCWorld (January 21, 2026) found it small and muddy. TechRadar (Josh Russell, June 21, 2026) said the Era 100 SL has "the same quality sound" as the Era 100. Cult of Mac (Ed Hardy, November 2, 2026) said the HomePod mini 2 improves on the original in almost every way. Tom's Guide (June 24, 2026) called the Google Home Speaker a modest upgrade over the discontinued Nest Audio that lacks features of Amazon and Apple speakers. The Nest Audio and Nest Mini are discontinued (9to5Google, June 21, 2026), so we do not recommend them.

What do owners complain about?

Alexa+ owners complain about slowness and broken routines, Google owners about lag and a subscription wall, and Sonos owners about the app; HomePod mini 2 is too new to have an owner pattern.

Best Buy, Walmart and Costco blocked our tools, so the retailer ratings we saw are search-result snippets from November 6, 2026 and not confirmed. Reddit was reachable only through a third-party mirror whose dates are approximate. We cannot give counts by complaint; the notes below are patterns in the threads we read, not a survey.

Alexa+ · routines

In an r/alexa thread (score 57, 51 comments) the author said a years-old grow-light routine broke after Alexa+, and commenters described broken time delays and wrong-room replies.

Alexa+ · speed

A 2025 Echo Studio owner wrote that replies were slow since day one; PCWorld called Alexa+ "still a work in progress" after two months with the Echo Dot Max.

Google · lag

BGR measured 5 to 10 seconds to turn on a light with the Google Home Speaker after a couple of weeks, against about half a second for Alexa; Engadget called the platform buggy.

Google · Nest speakers

On Nest Audio, an owner said "turn on the lights" now turns on every light in the house after the move to Gemini, and there is no way back to Google Assistant.

HomePod mini · 1st gen

Apple Community posters describe false triggers and unprompted music; after software 26.x, Apple Magazine reported network errors and stopped AirPlay, without counts.

Era 100 SL · limits

We found no owner failure threads for the SL; Sonos Community says it will not stereo pair with a Sonos One, One SL or Play:1, and Trueplay tuning is iPhone only.

Retailer snippets, unconfirmed: the first-generation HomePod mini shows about 4.6 stars on about 14,600 reviews at Best Buy, the Era 100 about 4.7 on 1,300 or more, and the Era 100 SL 4.7 on only 27, too few to call settled. We found no rating for the Echo Studio (2025), the HomePod mini 2 or the Google Home Speaker. A German site reported that Echo Dot Max alarms start late or stay silent (tink.de, September 21, 2026) and said an Amazon forum moderator confirmed a bug; we could not find that thread, so treat it as unconfirmed.

Can you go back to the old Alexa?

PCWorld (January 12, 2026) reported that you can say "Alexa, exit Alexa+", and Prof H Lab gives "Alexa, end Alexa+". We could not confirm the command still works now that Alexa+ is out of early access, and Amazon says the free chat tier on Alexa.com and the app cannot be deactivated. On Google speakers, PCWorld said the move to Gemini cannot be rolled back.

Should you buy now or wait for Black Friday?

Buy the Google Home Speaker now if you want it, wait for the Echo and Sonos models, and expect nothing on the HomePod mini 2.

Best Buy runs early deals from November 6 and Black Friday deals from November 19 to 28; Black Friday is November 27 and Cyber Monday November 30 (9to5Toys, October 27, 2026). Amazon has not announced its Black Friday week as of November 6. Prime Big Deal Days ran October 6 and 7. Past cuts below are percent figures from named outlets, and the prices are from the stores named.

SpeakerPrice seen (store, date)Deepest past cut we foundVerdict
Sonos Era 100 SL$189 at Sonos, Nov 6, 2026About 21% on Oct 6, 2026 (Gizmodo); 16% in JuneWait: buy at about $160 or less
Sonos Era 100$219 at Sonos, Nov 6, 202620% Black Friday 2023 (Engadget); 18% June 25, 2026 (9to5Toys)Wait: buy under $190
HomePod mini 2$149 at Apple, $149.99 at Target (Nov 6); $144.99 at Costco (Oct 23)None yet; 1st-gen mini best was 20% in 2022 (MacRumors)OK: $145 or less is fine; no rush
Google Home Speaker$79.99 at the Google Store through Dec 2 (Nov 6); list $99.9920% now, its first discount (9to5Google, Nov 2)Buy at $80 or less
Echo Dot Max$119.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6)10% Black Friday 2025, 25% May 2026, 35% June 2026 (9to5Toys, Gizmodo)Wait: under $95
Echo Studio (2025)$219.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6)About 14% Black Friday 2025 (9to5Toys)Wait: under $200

Our "wait" calls on Echo and Sonos rest on past depth, not an announced 2026 sale. A news report (Gigazine, August 24, 2026) said Amazon raised Echo prices on August 21, so do not assume last year's sale prices. We could not read Best Buy or Walmart prices today (their pages returned errors), so check them by hand; our dated store checks are on Price Check. Return windows we saw: Target 30 days on Echo and 14 on Apple, Sonos 30 days, Best Buy until January 15, 2027 for purchases from October 30. We found no recall of an Echo, HomePod, Google Home or Sonos speaker in the CPSC data from 2024 to November 5, 2026; our Recall Check page does not cover speakers.

Watch before you buy

Reviews show things text cannot, such as the lag and the light ring. We have not watched these in full, and they are independent creators, so follow the makers' pages where they differ.

▶Watch · video 1 of 3Digital Trends · English · Watch on YouTube

Why this one: a mainstream review of the one speaker that is on sale now.

▶Watch · video 2 of 3Digital Trends · English · Watch on YouTube

Why this one: it covers the no-microphone Era 100 SL, our first pick.

▶Watch · video 3 of 3Bud's Smart Home · English · Watch on YouTube

Why this one: an owner's view of Alexa+ and going back, which this guide could not test.

How do you do the five-minute privacy pass?

Set the history before the first command, keep training off, and learn where the mute is.

The five-minute privacy pass on a new speaker Do these before you ask it anything 1 Pick the history Alexa: set auto-delete to 3 months orchoose not to save. Google: leave 18months or shorten it. 2 Keep training off On Google, leave the voice and audioimprovement setting off. On Apple,decline Improve Siri. 3 Find the mute Echo has a mic button, Google and Era 100have a switch, HomePod mutes by voice orthe Home app. 4 Check the plan Alexa+ is free only with Prime. GeminiLive needs a Premium plan. 5 Delete old audio Use the app path for your brand once aquarter; Echo: More, Alexa Privacy. 6 Or skip the mic If the room is private, the Sonos Era 100SL has no microphones at all. Paths from the makers' privacy pages, read November 6, 2026; app menus change.
The privacy pass for a new speaker, from the makers' privacy pages read on November 6, 2026. The step people skip is deleting old audio.
  1. Choose the history. Alexa: More, Alexa Privacy, set auto-delete to 3 months or choose not to save (transcripts stay 30 days). Google: leave 18 months or shorten it.
  2. Keep training off. Google's "improve services with your voice and audio recordings" setting is off by default; leave it. Apple: decline Improve Siri.
  3. Find the mute. Echo: the mic button. Google Home Speaker and Era 100: a switch. HomePod mini: by voice or in the Home app.
  4. Check the plan. Alexa+ is free only with Prime; Gemini Live needs Premium.
  5. Delete old audio now and then: Echo through Alexa Privacy, Google through My Activity, Apple through Siri History.
  6. Or skip the microphone with the Era 100 SL.

What is the catch?

This guide compares documentation, not hands-on tests, and the best privacy answer is a speaker that cannot hear.

We read the makers' pages, published reviews and forum threads; we did not measure what any speaker sends. Settings and plans change: Alexa+ moved from early access to a paid plan within a year, and Apple has said Siri AI will expand access for a fee later. No product here was released more than about 16 months ago, so there are few long-term owner reports, and the Google Home Speaker and HomePod mini 2 have none. The Sonos Era 100 SL gives up voice entirely, and Alexa+ on the Era 100 is unconfirmed.

  • Menu names change between app versions; if a path differs, search the app settings for "privacy" or "history".
  • A free speaker plan can become a paid one; re-read the plan page before renewing.
  • Our verdicts depend on past discounts; an announced sale can change them.
Setting up a new smart speaker: in real life in real life · 4 panels 1 Unbox New speaker, new app, and a setup screen that asks about saving your voice. 2 Sonos Era 100 SL Choose what to keep Set the history to auto-delete, or not save, before the first command. 3 Check the plan Alexa+ and Gemini Live cost money if you lack Prime or Premium. Know it before you buy. 4 Mic off Press the mute switch when you want the room private, or buy the one with no mic.
A first evening with a new speaker, drawn from the steps in this guide. Choosing what to keep before the first command is the step that matters.

The bottom line: the Era 100 SL, unless you need a voice

If you want the speaker that records the least, buy the Sonos Era 100 SL, and wait for a deal near $160 if you can. If you need a voice, match the phone: HomePod mini 2 for iPhones, the Google Home Speaker for Android while it is $79.99, and an Echo only if you already pay for Prime. Whatever you choose, set the history before you ask the first question.

Price check: is today's price a good one?

How to use it: tap See today's price, then compare the price at checkout with our lines. At or under Good is a good buy; at or under Great is as low as we have seen it go at major US stores. The button opens the product on Amazon with today's price; the numbers here are prices seen at other stores and list prices, each with its source and date. We never quote prices from Amazon.

Wait for a saleAmazon Echo Dot Max (2025)
Good price: under $95 · Great: about $78
Model: Echo Dot Max (2025) smart speaker with Alexa+; not the Echo Dot 5th gen. Target holds $119.99 on Nov 6, 2026. Outlets reported 10% (Black Friday 2025), 25% (May 2026) and 35% (June 2026) off; Best Buy's Nov 19-28 window is the next chance.
Seen at other stores: $119.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026
Wait for a saleAmazon Echo Studio (2025)
Good price: under $200 · Great: about $176
Model: Echo Studio (2025, the smaller model) with Alexa+. Target $219.99 on Nov 6, 2026. The Black Friday 2025 low was about 14% off (9to5Toys, Dec 12, 2025).
Seen at other stores: $219.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026
Fair priceApple HomePod mini (2nd generation)
Good price: $145 or less · Great: about $129
Model: HomePod mini 2nd generation (S10 chip), on sale Oct 30, 2026. New models are rarely cut in their first holiday; the first-generation mini's best Black Friday cut was 20% (2022). Siri AI is not shipped yet.
Seen at other stores: $149 at Apple; $149.99 at Target (Nov 6, 2026); $144.99 at Costco (Oct 23, 2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026
Buy nowGoogle Home Speaker
Good price: $80 or less · Great: about $70
Model: Google Home Speaker with Gemini for Home (June 2026); not the Nest Audio. Cut to $79.99 on Nov 2, 2026 through Dec 2, its first discount, so the sale spans Black Friday. Deeper cuts are possible (Nest Audio hit 50% in 2024) but none is reported.
Seen at other stores: $79.99 at the Google Store through Dec 2, 2026 (list $99.99) · checked Nov 6, 2026
Wait for a saleSonos Era 100
Good price: under $190 · Great: about $175
Model: Sonos Era 100 with microphones (not the Era 100 Pro or the SL). Sonos ran 20% off at Black Friday 2023 (Engadget) and 18% on June 25, 2026 (9to5Toys). Its 2026 Black Friday sale is not announced.
Seen at other stores: $219 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026
Wait for a saleSonos Era 100 SL
Good price: under $160 · Great: about $149
Model: Sonos Era 100 SL, the model with no microphones. About 21% off ($149) on Oct 6, 2026 (Gizmodo) and 16% in June; a repeat in the Black Friday window is likely but not confirmed.
Seen at other stores: $189 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026

Every price check, by category →

Our first pick, and our last word
The exact speakers to order, and what to check on the listing
The pickSonos Era 100 SL
Pick: Era 100 SL in black or white. The "SL" is the model without microphones; the plain Era 100 looks the same and has mics.
Check: Sold and shipped by a named retailer or Sonos, not a third-party seller; the box says Era 100 SL; keep the receipt, Sonos gives 30-day returns on its own store.
$189 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026). About 21% off ($149) on Oct 6, 2026 per Gizmodo · Nov 2026
Best for iPhone homesApple HomePod mini (2nd generation)
Pick: The 2nd-generation HomePod mini ($149), not the first-generation mini that stores may still sell.
Check: Listing says 2nd generation or HomePod mini (2026); it needs HomePod software 27.2; Apple's warranty is one year.
$149 at Apple and $149.99 at Target (Nov 6, 2026) · Nov 2026
Best for Google homesGoogle Home Speaker
Pick: Google Home Speaker in any colour; the listing must say Google Home Speaker, not the older Google Home or Nest Audio.
Check: Check the sale price against the Google Store ($79.99 to Dec 2) before paying more; confirm the Premium trial length on the Google Store page.
$79.99 at the Google Store, from $99.99, through Dec 2, 2026 (Google Store, Nov 6 · Nov 2026
Best for Alexa homesAmazon Echo Dot Max (2025)
Pick: Echo Dot Max (2025). It is not the Echo Dot (5th gen) or the Echo Pop.
Check: The listing says Echo Dot Max, with the Alexa+ line; shipped by a named retailer or Amazon itself.
$119.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026). Past cuts of 10% (Black Friday 2025), 25% (May 2026) and 35% (June 2026) per 9to5Toys and Gizmodo · Nov 2026
Best Alexa soundAmazon Echo Studio (2025)
Pick: Echo Studio (2025, the smaller one), not the 2019 model.
Check: About 40% smaller than the 2019 Echo Studio; the 2025 box says Alexa+.
$219.99 at Target, no sale (Nov 6, 2026). Black Friday 2025 low was about 14% off (9to5Toys, Dec 12, 2025) · Nov 2026
The sound pickSonos Era 100
Pick: Era 100 (not the Era 100 Pro, an installer model, and not the SL).
Check: Mic switch on the back; sold by Sonos or a named retailer, not a third-party seller.
$219 at Sonos (Nov 6, 2026). Past cuts: 20% (Black Friday 2023, Engadget), 18% (June 25, 2026, 9to5Toys) · Nov 2026
The buttons are paid links: as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, and it never changes what you pay. Prices in this guide come from Target, Apple, Costco, Sonos and the Google Store on November 6, 2026 and move with sales; the buttons show today's price.

More of our guides for the occasion

Sorting out the other room: our guide to TVs with the fewest AI features.
Updated November 2, 2026
Planning the whole sale week: our Black Friday tech and car deals guide.
Updated October 14, 2026

Quick answers

Is Alexa+ free with Prime?

Yes. Amazon says Alexa+ is included at no additional cost to Prime members and costs $19.99 a month otherwise (Amazon, updated September 1, 2026).

How much does Alexa+ cost without Prime over three years?

$719.64 at $19.99 a month for 36 months. Non-Prime users also get a limited free chat tier on Alexa.com and the app.

Can I go back to the old Alexa?

PCWorld reported in January 2026 that you can say "Alexa, exit Alexa+". We could not confirm it still works after the September 2026 launch, so test it on your device.

Does Alexa record everything you say?

Amazon says Echo devices record after the wake word and keep recordings until you set auto-delete (3 or 18 months) or choose not to save. A 2020 university study found accidental activations of 1.5 to 19 times a day on older speakers and no evidence of constant recording.

Can I stop Echo from sending recordings to the cloud?

Not on current models. In March 2025 Amazon removed that switch, which only three models had. You can choose not to save recordings, and the mic button cuts power to the microphones.

Does HomePod record conversations?

Apple says audio is not stored unless you opt in to Improve Siri. Requests are tied to a random identifier for 6 months; delete them in the Home app under Siri History.

HomePod mini 2 vs HomePod mini 1: is it worth it?

Cult of Mac found it better in almost every way for $149, but Siri AI is not out yet, so only classic Siri works today. The first generation is no longer on Apple's buy page.

Google Home Speaker vs Echo Dot Max: which is better?

For Google homes, the Home Speaker, at $79.99 to December 2. For Alexa homes with Prime, the Echo Dot Max. Both owners we read complain about lag or routines. Both have paid tiers: Premium and Alexa+.

Do I need a subscription for Gemini on the Google Home Speaker?

Not for basics such as music, timers and home control. Gemini Live and some features need Google Home Premium at $10 or $20 a month, according to the Google Store on November 6, 2026.

Is there a smart speaker without a microphone?

Yes: the Sonos Era 100 SL. Sonos says it has no internal microphones and no voice control, and it works with the Sonos app, AirPlay and Bluetooth.

How this guide was made. On November 6, 2026 we read the makers' privacy and plan pages (Amazon, Apple, Google, Sonos), reviews from Tom's Guide, TechRadar, Engadget, PCWorld, BGR and Cult of Mac, Sonos Community and Apple Community threads, Reddit threads through a third-party mirror, and store listings at Target, Apple, Sonos, the Google Store and Costco. Best Buy, Walmart and Costco blocked our tools, so retailer ratings and some prices are search-result snippets and are marked as unconfirmed; Wirecutter, The Verge and CNET could not be read. We quote no star ratings, review counts or prices from Amazon, and the buttons show today's price. We did not test these speakers ourselves. No product photos are shown because we could not confirm that the makers license their press photos for commercial use. Drafted with AI assistance and checked by the Verdict Picks editors on November 6, 2026. Product names are trademarks of their owners; Verdict Picks is not affiliated with or endorsed by Amazon, Apple, Google or Sonos.

Echo vs HomePod vs Google vs Sonos in 2026: what Alexa+ costs over three years, what each smart speaker records and which to buy (Verdict Picks)

Save this guide for later

Pin it to your Pinterest board and it will be there when the sale hits.

Save to Pinterest
Follow Verdict Picks

Get the next guide when it lands

A new guide most days: researched picks only, no sale pitches. Pick the way you like to follow:

Every option explained, and what we will never send: the follow page.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are those seen at US retailers at the time of writing (November 2026), are subject to change, and the price shown on Amazon at checkout is the one that applies. We do not accept products or payment from manufacturers. How we rank · Disclosure

Comments

Popular posts from this blog